Evidence in Waxing part 2

Once i had take the ribbing in brown wax we compared it to the green rubbing from.the Strawberry Mansion longcase clock back

A match and more than likely that piece on the clock is a offcut.


Cadwalader V the furniture expert 

Over the past 4 years of researching the Philadelphia bed made for General John and Elizabeth Cadwalader only one objection keep coming up.
“The bed is English”. 

Made in Philadelphia between late 1768-70

This has been a frustration as the beds mechanics show clearly that the secondary timbers are traditionally used in American Antique Furniture making unlike the lack of Oak, Pine or Mahogany which is expected to be used on a quality piece like this made in 18th Century Britain.

With all the other research and evidence which clearly connects to the surviving Cadwalader paperwork from the craftsmen involved with the refurbishment of there new 2nd Street home. 

They bought 1768  for which they wanted the furniture and interior to have a English feel of the last fashion from the UK but made in Philadelphia.

New evidence came to my attention back in Oct last year thanks to Christopher Storb WordPress ( 30th October 2016) a conservator at The Philadelphia Museum of Art which his blogs on the Strawberry Mansion longcase clock that had been on long-term loan to the Philadelphia Museum of Art before going to Christie’s New York for sale No 2414 in 24 January  2011 Lot 59.

Strawberry mansion clock Christie’s 2011

From Mr Storb article shows a number of image of the clock hood mainly the facade but for the last one is showing the back and its construction.

Strawberry mansion clock hood back by C Storb

The arched section dovetailed across the back got my attention. The markings left by a chip out of a plan iron, marks I had see before and they are very pratical.

I found the clock and got the Curator to send me a wax rubbing of that hole back piece.

Wax rubbing back of the clock hood

This rubbing I took to the bed in storage and did a brown rubbing taken from the back of the bed canopy.

Brown rubbing from the bed canopy over laid the clock rubbing

Once done I over layed then to see and they were a perfect match with sizing and execution. 

This means one thing that the canopy and clock section had been planed by the same man with the hand tool. In fact the piece on the clock is a off-cut from the bed 

Showing the chip line which were left by a craftsmen

This is clear evidence that the bed was made in one workshop in Philadelphia and with the connection and attributation to James Reynolds who carved the clock. Then its more than likely  constructed in Benjamin Randolph shop between late 1768 -70.
Scholars have talked about the importance of evidence left by tools marks from the craftsmen in Colonial furniture which again we don’t see on English 18th century period furniture of this quality.

This evidence and method will open up new research plus the opportunity of finding of other Philadelphia piece with these markings which are all time relative that can be put into this one workshop, one craftsmens, one chip plane iron 

Timothy Garland 

Lincoln UK

14 May 2017 


The Case for Cadwalader 

The case for Cadwalader is the article title in the new Vol II of Mortise and Tenon Magazine. It a journey through from how we went from a photograph in a book published in 1910 to restoring and then the roller coaster ride that followed.

Evidence up on evidence has been found both physically by being left by the craftsmen and the paperwork of the Cadwalader family held in The Pennsylvania Historical Society.

A lot has been said about the bed being English and cut down both are very much untrue with the timber analysis showing American timbers as the secondary woods.

Even the top of the bed post show clearly that they hve not been cut or aulter and showing hammered marks.

So with this and other evidence it been and all keep pointing to the lost John and Elizabeth Cadwalader bed but one new and very important find has happened.
Something so simple but is so compelling that it brings together a number of the rarest and most important furniture made in Philadelphia between 1768-71

1st is the Cadwalader games table in the PMA

Philadelphia Museum of Art

2 Fox and Grape High Chest 

Philadelphia Museum of Art

3 Richard Butts attributed carved games table sold in Sotheby’s Jan 2017.

Sotheby’s New York 2017

4 The Cadwalader bed

Without hangings

All plus one other piece have anomaly noth seen on other piece made inside or out side of Philadelphia. These marks are very rare and from a chip out of a plane iron blade. All time relevant and not all over the bed. Just the canopy.

Showing the markings
Showing the comparison with another piece of Philadelphia furniture that also not left American and in a private collection in the blue green colour and the brown taken from the bed. 

Clearly showing the rubbing that both sections of timber have been planed by the same man and his plane alone.

Evidence which cannot be questioned that helps put this bed and all the original components have been made in Philadelphia 1768-9.


The Case for John Cadwalader’s Bed


After three and a half years of reaching the mechanics of this bed constructed by using secondary Colonial timbers of birch and tulip poplar we are on the last few weeks before the Mortice and Tenon magazine is released.

Both for myself and Ian Coulson it has been a very bumpy road of ups and downs by highs of excitement when we have found a connection which has taken us on another journey of discovery within the workshop practices happening only in Philadelphia between 1768-70.

Even in the last few weeks new physical evidence has been found to added another recorded Philadelphia piece of furniture into a small group that were made more than likely in a conveyer belt way. 

Image showing the difference in timber where the walnut was use to repair.
This too is new and unpublished research but go’s  back to a observation made when Winterthur Museum published The Cadwalader Furniture Study mid 1990s. But the connection is very compeling and nothing to do with the facade or decoration by carving. Constructional from the beginning.

Regarding the downs we had a few mainly based on opinions that its not correct or John Cadwalader its English. These options have been made in most cases very quickly and at the very early stages,  but when we have looked closely and cross referenced them they have very little grounding.

Then again the opposition we must thank because it made little sence to the bed that stood in front of us. It made us both more determined to do due diligence on both the physical and Cadwalader paperwork which survived.

This is a article which takes you through the basic travelling time we had from first seeing and knowing about the bed from a photograph published in 1910 to the  auction through the restoration and then the science and paper-trail . 

This magazine is a must for all Students and Experts of American Period Furniture.

Lookforward to opening the John Cadwalader bed debate further please see the link below 

A roller coaster ride through mid 18th Century Philadelphia 

I remember sitting on the London Tube getting across town to Liverpool Street Station to meet my girlfriend  (who became Mrs G) while reading the London Evening News. In the arts and book section was a review of a new publication called Manchester United Ruined My Life by Colin   Shindler.

As a Manchester City supporter thanks to my departed father, I to read it which was very well written about the ups and downs of City fan.

This book has somewhat  faded in my memory but it got me thing about the last 3.5 years of my life.

What started out as a phone call between friends with a interest and passion for period antique furniture could eventually take us on a roller coaster ride of highs to the lows which Shindler also talks about.

How can a object in this case a four poster bed corse the sea sickness of emotions on a journey trying to understand and workout the manufacturer, materials and its history as well as working out some anomalies and mechanics not found throughout English production in the Georgian period.

My connection to this project is from the start unlike my normal restoration jobs which are pieces generally made for the practical domestic market of the 18th &early 19th Century which have very little or no need for research.  This was very different because this piece was found, examined, bought and then restored which opened  up this to me a new road  of discovery and hard nocks communicating with experts who know nothing of me or my background skills.

I have just had the privilege to read my article in the forth coming Mortise and Tenon Magazine in USA which takes you through the hole story as if in our shoes.

The M&T Magazine team are a very exciting and passion group who want to bring everyone to the table when it comes to learning & understanding American furniture history and constructing/manufacturing.

From the cabinetmaker -restorer -conservator- curator -the Student of furniture and then the experts come scholars to open up listen by  share old and new knowledge and finding which will shed light on furniture which had been put to one side.

My article is this journey about a bed made for John and Elizabeth Cadwalader and how like Shindler we all have a passion  and with me its Antique Furniture and  finding this John Cadwalader bed has it  ruin my life Yes in someways from frustrations of being on the wrong side of the pond but also has made me more determined to get a platform to speak . 

Mortise and Tenon Magazine a recommended read for all students of American Furniture.

The Philadelphia connection 

Something has always puzzled me about carved decoration found on a number of the very best period Philadelphia mahogany furniture which have been made between a 10 year period of 1760-70.

What has court my eye is a simple circles which have been lightly  carved out by probably the carver using a small gouge.

There really is nothing strange about them as they’ve  blend in with the other caving but i have found very little research on them and why,  as they are not found on every piece of carved mid 18th century Philly furniture but seem to be on the most expensive..

They seem not to be found on any other furniture mades and  carved from other East Coast States of this period.

John & Elizabeth Cadwalader bed

First piece that came to my attention was when I was restoring the damaged polish  of all the showwood  from the John Cadwalader bed ( photo 2). 

Showing a section from the front carving while removing the bad polish

We noticed the circular carving, each one is different showing they have been executed free hand and placed in the sunk parts of the canopy eg the concave section at the top scolap areas but we could not find at the time a connection but now after 3 and 1/2 years of research by myself and Ian Coulson this circling with the other physical evidence is drawing me to the the fact that this bed was made in Philadelphia in late 1768-9.

The image below got me to look at it twice when I was reading Wallace Nutting VOL III of Furniture Treasury

 This drawing was taken from a Philadelphia piece of furniture but this too had the circular marks also in set  on  the concave sections. While going through the book i came across another Philadelphia furniture which had making too.

Both drawing got me looking at the bed again and its real connection to America at a time of some of the best Rococo furniture.

Now i have started looking into this more deeply by looking at the known piece but a large number of Auctioneers catalogues online or hard back and museums collections show great images but not good enough to see this finer details like the ones below

I am looking to build up the know piece with or without information of the makers and carvers who were involved in furniture making.

Carved canopy in position after restoration

When in Philadelphia late 1760s

Over last nearly 4 years myself and Ian Coulson have been researching this bed which is made of carved mahogany for the footpost and bolt covers.

Over all the bed has been tested with timber analysis and finish examination both have opened up some very interesting finds. (More to come in the new volume of Mortise and Tenon Magazine)

It was  while I was finishing of this article I came across a piece of furniture which has anomaly that has been recorded on a games table in the Philadelphia Museum of Art.

Winterthur Museum published The Cadwalader Furniture Study  where they researched and finish tested known Cadawalader piece of furniture out of Museums and Private hands.

This study shows the history of each piece through finishes and repairs, it also openes up new findings regarding leg construction method,  one we have not seen in period furniture making in the UK but there findings also found anomaly on the  underside of the Games table  (PMA).

Last weekend after reading a blog form a furniture Conservator regarding proportion which he uses for his reference a bit of furniture which had sold through a leading American Auctioneers.

It came with a impressive write up regarding its connection to a Carver this by the evidence left by his hand skills. It also stated that it was made in Philadelphia by design and execution plus backed  by independent furniture experts.

While looking closely at these fantastic images which included close up detail shots something  court my eye. It was not the fantastic carved decoration to the facade or the way the finish had broken down with age but for a simple photograph taken showing the back and its construction.

Just a few seconds of looking at the image the anomaly jumped out at me.

Why so quickly because i had seen it before first hand which was when we examined the bed at auction and then closer examination when the showwood of the bed was being restored.

This anomaly felt behind by a craftsmen and his tool in the preparation of the timber on the piece taken from the blog is more than likely to be the same timber aa used on the carved removable showwood canopy of the bed. Its shows the same dark staining and light colour orange timber on the edges leaving us to believe that the bed canopy and the piece from the saleroom are from the same workshop in Philadelphia circa late 1766s to 1770.

We can now  add two fully documented bits of furniture connected to Philadelphia and with them add the bed and all its evidence to the fact that all three came from the same workshop.

Research is still on going.